My Extremely Naive And Innocent Brain Wept After Learning About These Dark True Crime Cases

    "Gary Lee Bullock is my husband's cousin and he bludgeoned a priest to death in Eureka, California on New Year's Day 2014."

    Do you love all things scary, dark, and creepy? Subscribe to the That Got Dark newsletter to get your weekly dopamine fix of the macabre delivered RIGHT to your inbox!

    BuzzFeed header with the text "THAT GOT DARK" in a horror-themed font over a background showing faint, eerie faces

    A little while back we asked the BuzzFeed Community to tell us about a more obscure true crime story they felt more people should be talking about. Here are their bone-chilling responses:

    Note: Mentions of extreme violence, abuse, rape, and murder ahead.

    1. The shocking case of Katherine Knight, who was convicted for the gruesome murder of her boyfriend, John Charles Thomas Price in February 2000 in New South Wales, Australia. She became the first one in Australian history to be given a life sentence without parole.

    her during a police interview

    2. The disappearance of Ann Mineko Racz in Newhall, California in 1991. Although Ann's body has never been found, she is believed to have been murdered by her estranged husband, a former LA County Sheriff’s sergeant, John Racz.

    Aerial view of a highway cutting through arid, hilly terrain with mountains in the background, illustrating a scenic, expansive landscape

    3. The cryptic case of Franchesca Alvarado, who disappeared while on a trip to Atlantic City with an unidentified older man in 2012.

    her missin person posters

    4. The highly disturbing case of seven-year-old Ondrej and nine-year-old Jakub Mauerova who were severely abused by their mother Klara (pictured below), which included feeding their flesh to relatives, in the Czech Republic in 2008.

    Person biting their lip with a thoughtful expression, wearing dangling earrings and a necklace

    5. The violent murder of Katie Janness and her partner's dog Bowie who were found stabbed to death outside the entrance to Piedmont Park in Atlanta, Georgia in 2021.

    the news segment with camera visual of her walking a dog

    6. The ongoing case of Dahlia Bolin, a 16-year-old teen in rural Illinois who is facing charges of first-degree murder, attempted first-degree murder, solicitation of murder for hire, solicitation of murder, and conspiracy to commit murder in the deadly shooting of her mother, Rebecca Bolin on Oct. 22, 2021.

    A handgun and bullets sit on a pile of hundred-dollar bills, suggesting themes of crime or wealth

    7. The appalling death of five-year-old Logan Marr in Maine in 2001. Logan, and her younger sister Bailey, had been in the care of a woman named Sally Schofield (pictured below) at the time. Schofield was eventually convicted of manslaughter in Logan's death.

    Two people seated attentively in a courtroom setting, audience visible in the background

    8. The strange disappearance of 16-year-old Ruth Wilson in Box Hill, Surrey, England in 1995.

    school photo of her

    9. The controversial and highly suspicious death of Private First Class LaVena Lynn Johnson who was found dead in her tent in Iraq in July 2005. Although her death was ruled a suicide by the Department of Defense, her family argues there was evidence suggesting she'd been raped and murdered.

    banner made in remembrance of her

    10. The Port Arthur massacre, a mass shooting that happened in Tasmania, Australia on April 28, 1996. The killer, Martin Bryant, killed 35 people, including children, and wounded 23 more.

    A quaint house with a damaged roof beside a smoking structure. Two people stand nearby, and a fire truck is parked on a driveway. Forest in the background

    11. The gruesome triple homicide of an elderly couple, who were tortured before their death, and their deaf and nearly-blind son in the Boise foothills of Idaho in 2015.

    news story with people in court

    12. The case of Anna Maciejewska from Malvern, Pennsylvania who has been missing since 2017 and whose case is being investigated as a homicide.

    closeup of her on a news segment

    13. The terrible Parker-Hulme murder case in Christchurch, New Zealand in June 1954, which actually inspired the Peter Jackson film Heavenly Creatures.

    black and white photo of women walking out of a home

    14. The mysterious and upsetting death of a young girl named Sara Keesling in Riverside, California in 1988 that didn't get enough attention.

    Aerial view of a cityscape featuring urban buildings, roads, and hills in the distance under a clear sky

    15. The horrifying case of mass murderer John List who methodically killed his wife, three children, and mother at their home in Westfield, New Jersey in 1971 believing it was "the only way to ensure their safe arrival in heaven."

    16. The unthinkable and extremely violent killing and dismemberment of Aliahna Lemmon, a nine-year-old girl in Fort Wayne, Indiana by Michael Plumadore, a family friend who was babysitting her in 2011.

    him handcuffed with officers walking behind him

    17. David Parker Ray, aka the Toy-Box Killer, who was active in the '90s in New Mexico. The moniker came from the fact that he would chain and torture women in his soundproofed "toy box," a semi-trailer.

    closeup of a man in a suit and tie in court

    18. The tragic case of Keith Warren, a Black teenager who was found hanging from a tree in Maryland in 1986, and whose case was believed to be mishandled and "erroneously ruled a suicide."

    closeup of his photo on a news segment

    19. The horrible case of Seth Privacky, who shot and killed his parents, grandfather, brother, and his brother's girlfriend in November 1998 in Muskegon, Michigan.

    him taking the stand in a courtroom

    20. The deplorable case of Marcus Wesson, a mass murderer, abuser, and rapist — including the rape of his own underage daughters and nieces — who is responsible for one of Fresno, California's most horrific crimes. His crimes spanned several decades, from the 1970s until the mid-2000s.

    I don’t know who this is, but a man with long hair and a beard is sitting in what appears to be a courtroom, wearing a beige suit

    21. The awful case of Jeff Pelo, a former Bloomington Police Sergeant who was convicted of repeatedly assaulting four women and stalking a fifth woman in Bloomington, Illinois from 2002–2006.

    him in an interrogation room

    22. The case of Robert Garrow, a serial rapist and spree killer who was active in upstate New York in the 1970s. The case turned a bizarre twist when his lawyers refused to disclose the location of the bodies of two of his victims in what became known as the "Buried Bodies Case."

    Two police officers assist a man in a wheelchair, helping him exit a building

    23. The horrifying case of Anthony Sowell aka "The Cleveland Strangler" or "The Imperial Avenue Murderer," a serial killer who was active in Cleveland, Ohio in 2009.

    House behind yellow caution tape, suggesting a restricted area or investigation scene. Residential neighborhood with similar houses visible

    24. The disappearance of Wetumpka, Alabama resident Traci Pittman Kegley in 1998. Her car was found abandoned with her unharmed two-year-old daughter, purse, and ID still inside.

    A car is parked in a dense wooded area, partially hidden by tall grass and trees

    25. The nightmarish case of Allan Legere, an arsonist, rapist, and serial killer who was active in New Brunswick, Canada in the 1980s.

    his wanted poster

    26. The awful case of Thomas Koskovich & Jayson Vreeland, aka the "Pizza Killers," who committed their crimes in Franklin, New Jersey in 1997.

    Two car headlights shine brightly in a darkened setting, illuminating the area directly ahead on what appears to be a nighttime road

    27. The horrible case of the "Hangman" or "Killer Cop", aka Gerard John Schaefer Jr., a former sheriff's deputy and suspected serial killer active in Florida in the '70s.

    closeup of him smiling

    28. The case of Bruce McArthur, a serial killer active in the 2010s in Toronto, Canada who targeted marginalized people, primarily gay men of color.

    People in white protective suits gather items in a snowy residential area, placing them into a van

    29. The Ant Hill Kids cult, formed by Roch Thériault in Canada, which was active from the '70s to the '80s.

    closeup of him

    30. Finally, the terrifying case of Gary Lee Bullock, who had only been out of jail for a few hours when he committed the violent murder of a beloved priest in Eureka, California in 2014.

    his mug shot on a news segment

    Note: Some submissions have been edited for length and/or clarity.

    Is there a lesser-known true crime story you think more people should know about? Tell us in the comments below or via this anonymous form:

    Are you obsessed with this kind of content? Subscribe to the That Got Dark newsletter to get your weekly dopamine fix of the macabre delivered RIGHT to your inbox!

    BuzzFeed graphic with the text "That Got Dark" over a shadowy, eerie background

    If you or anyone you know has information on a missing person case, call local law enforcement first. You can also contact the National Center for Missing & Exploited Children at 1-800-843-5678 (THE-LOST) or visit the National Missing and Unidentified Persons System site for regional case assistance.